By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Rpruett on 17 January 2011
Edit Thread
AussieGecko said:
Rpruett said:

What point are you trying to make?   Are you still trying to portay this idea that Kinect has better games for it?   Going by Metacritic,  Move has better, more, quality games for it when compared to Kinect.  Whether the controls are tacked on, or not it doesn't matter.  


How so most people are comparing move only games to kinect only games. Heavy Rain etc a lot of them are better on controller so you cant really include them as being a strong point for the move. Those games seem to have Move support simply tact on, hey why doesnt kinect do a mini game for the halos mass effects and other high scoring games... Because those games were not designed for kinect and the controller would be chosen for them if you could. 

I am not saying they wouldnt be perfect for kinect, well i am for halo but mass effect would be awesome for it. But MS didnt, they decided to make games for Kinect and get other companies to make games for Kinect, games that will be hybrid will be designed for both.

That is absurd logic.  These games being better on controller is a matter of personal preference.  Much like (I hate the Xbox 360 controller and prefer the PS3 one to it).   Sure you can count great games that incorporate Move support as 'Move' games.     

Take Resident Evil for example,  I had absolutely no interest in this game when it launched.  It broke away from the standard RE formula and felt more survival horror to me from the demo than how the game used to play out.  Shortly after I bought Move,  I went out and purchased Resident Evil (Specifically for Move and won't touch it with anything else) so my brother and I can co-op through the story.    Having a ton of fun with it and couldn't see myself ever using a controller with it.    

And the reason you don't see Kinect with Halo or Mass Effect is because they CAN'T do it yet.  Not on a primary full-fledged sense. They have yet to find a way to do it intuitively.  Believe me, if Microsoft could include Kinect support in everything they most certainly would.  Move support isn't 'mini-games' in most of the games listed, it is full-fledged 100% control scheme using the Move.