Who is right, me or Chibi?

[Chibi.V.29]

Immortal said:

voty2000 said:

My problem with predictions on this site is that most people make very uniformed predications.  Instead of using facts as a guideline, they use fanboy drivel.  I enjoy reading peoples predictions when they back them up whether they turn out true or false.  They used the best information they had at the time to make a guess, which is great. 

Recently, some people have predicted that Kinect will fall off the face of the earth after this holiday season.   There is no good reasoning to come up with this prediction other than they want it to fail.  The only argument that could be used is that there is little software support, but this is flawed because we do not know what MS has planned for next year.  These people are assuming that MS will stop supporting Kinect which is simply ridiculous. 

Bottom line:  Informed predictions are great, fanboy drivel sucks.

I agree with you completely on the first part. If somebody had told me before the PS3 Slim announcement that the PS3 would peak in 2010, I wouldn't give them credit for getting it right because it was just fanboyish hope that led them to believe it - not reason. If, looking at how things were going, somebody had said that the Wii would be at 75m sales by 2010 back in late 2008, I wouldn't serve them crow later simply because they were using the best resources available to them and were predicting the most likely result, even if they were 10m off.

EDIT - Oh, and this is hillarious! Every one of my arguments with Chibi results in its own thread. It's ike some sort of curse, xD.

Actual only 2 did and i dont put your name int he title or article :P we have had about 6 so im ignoring you from know on :P As the way you say things even when i agree annoys me >_>