I don't like it, and looking at the poll of the YouTube-video most people seem to think the same way.
The D-pad definitely looks like an improvement, but the original D-pad is so bad that it would be impossible to make it even worse.
What I really don't like is the buttons being gray. I really liked the colored buttons, that was pretty much the only thing I prefered about the 360 gamepad in comparison to the PS3 pad.







