By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
geddesmond2 on 01 January 2011
Edit Thread
starcraft said:
geddesmond2 said:
starcraft said:

It only started to be a woefully useless article when he said more good exclusives are coming this year for PS3 than Xbox 360, thereby making great assumptions about unreleased titles.

Unfortunately, he made this error early on, thereby setting the tone for the rest of the text.


But your making assumption based on unnannounced titles too. For all you know MS could announce 3 new titles by E3 of next year and then another 6 at E3 for christmas 2011/2012 but Sony could do the same thing aswel. Hes basing his opinion on what he knows is coming. Your basing your opinion on speculation and stuff you hope is coming. See the differance there.

But he doesn't know what is coming, anymore than I do.  I didn't attempt to form an opinion because I know that at this point noone is in a position to form a reliable opinion on the end quality of each console's line-up for 2011.

Remember, there was a time when Lair was going to be the exclusive of the year.

Well thats not true considering that over half a dozen titles headed to the PS3 next year are sequels to games that scored really well with critics. Your talking about Lair but that game was a new IP. These games coming are established and well liked titles.

He took a look at what each consol has to offer next year. Seen MS only have 2 established titles announced so far that scored pretty well with critics, took a look at what the PS3 had to offer and made his opinion based on that. Thats enough to form a very reliable opinion in my books.