World of Warcraft with Kinect

[daroamer]

leatherhat said:

daroamer said:

leatherhat said:

daroamer said:

leatherhat said:

yo_john117 said:

ImJustBayuum said:

yo_john117 said:

Wow I guess this just proves that KINECT will work with core games just fine....just have to have someone creative enough behind it to make it work.

Its proven for the PC not for the consoles

Ummmm no i'm saying that this video proves that KINECT will work with core games.

Its being supplemented with additional software is what he's saying. It wouldn't work on xbox. Not that you should want it to, pumping your fist into the air is far from an intuitive control scheme.

You're right, no human could ever program this on a 360!  It's unpossible!

It would depend on the resources used by it

Ah, so you think WoW graphics would stress the 360?

Im talking about the resources used by the FAAST program. 

Your original statements were pretty absolute "Its being supplemented with additional software" "It wouldn't work on xbox." Without actually know what is and isn't possible on the 360 you might want to refrain from stating definitively that you know something won't work.

Back on topic.

Kinect games should be designed for Kinect controls, no one is saying that Kinect should replace the input method that a game was DESIGNED for.  People constantly talk about how much better a controller is compared to Kinect but would you want to play WoW with a controller?  That would be as fun as trying to play it with Kinect, which is say not very much fun at all, because it was designed to function with a keyboard and mouse. 

As much as people hail the almightly controller (especially it seems in Kinect threads), playing WoW with it would be an exercise in frustration.  So would your conclusion then be that controllers are horrible as an input device?