Was it really that good? in a nutshell............. NO.
Just like GTA IV all it had going for it were high production values, but overall the gameplay was poor and clunky, even walking was retarded, and the less said about horse riding play the better.
I got over 600G's for it and completed the game, so i am not making this judgement based on playing the game for only a couple of hours or so.
Sorry, but i don't even consider it to be best western game out there either.
I would give that award to GUN on xbox/ps2.
Now THATS a fun game to play.







