34. Bioshock
I know I'm not breaking any new ground like the 20 or so other people who put this game #35-30 on their list, but Bioshock is AWESOME!!! I tried before to plat this bitch, but nope. The hardest playthrough trophy is like the Stanley Cup in which it's full of piss (hockey reference you probably didn't understand). It's worth mentioning that this game single handily drove home the "ps3 ain't got no gamez" campaign that took place in late 2007.
Good job Bioshock, you showed those ps3 fanbots whose boss!