2011's GOTY race to be a very close one!

[iBlah]

DaHuuuuuudge said:

iBlah said:

tolu619 said:

ConnorJCP said:

Exactly, Uncharted 3, if anything like the last, will destroy the competition.

Wait! The other 3 games are from 2006 and Uncharted 2 is from 2009! Not too fair a comparison.

oh sure, Kobe Bryant is not a better basketball player than some random nameless bench sitting NBA dude in 60s because they're from different generations, not too fair a comparison.

You missed the point, he's saying that the games from 2006 took away GOTY awards from each other/

and you're missing the point that a better game IS a better game, regardless when it is released or how many other games are released at the same time. Critically, Uncharted 2 IS the better game of the bunch with 96 metascrore after over 100 reviews, it would have been just as good if it was released in 2006, if a game that is as good as Uncharted 2 was released in 2006, it would just have the same reception as it was in 2009. speak of 2009 competition, what about Batman: AA? one game that wowed everyone, or Modern Warfare 2? the biggest blockbuster release of its time.