CGI's HYPE Series: Graphics Showdown 2011

[snfr]

RAZurrection said:

 

snfr said:

LoL, you didn't get my point as it seems. I didn't say there isn't any difference, I said you don't see it, and you don't see it because you will never see Drake's face so close if it isn't a cutscene.

Uh, I can move the camera anywhere I want, you've made a fatal flaw though, you're assuming everyone can't tell a difference between a video and something generated at real time. I can and it is as easy to spot as 30fps vs 60fps. I guess you're one of those people who doesn't.

snfr said:

You probably won't do the same type of comparison for a 360 or multiplatform game

Why wouldn't I? Do tell. In fact I heartilly would welcome the challange. Post any (unaltered) pic of you like from any console game with a pre-rendered "in engine" shot and another shot of the same engine in real-time and I will be able to tell you exactly which is which.

snfr said:

I still don't get what you're trying to desperately prove here. Not that you only complain about CGI's choice of pics and derailed the thread, you also try to bad-mouth Uncharted 2's graphics.

I don't see how agreeing with the developer that the PS3 cannot do U's cutscenes in real-time is bad mouthing it. It's a simple fact, although according to some people here, not a very well known or understood one.

snfr said:

Buy a PS3, put down your bias, play Uncharted 2, then come back and discuss properly. (Just for you to know: I have all three consoles, I like them all, and I don't bad-mouth games that I don't like or didn't play, so...)

I have played the game to completion from the heist to shambala, there's a significant difference in the real-time graphics and the pre-rendered ones. Just because you can't see it doesn't mean its not there.

snfr said:

Btw, I still think it's funny that you claimed that the ME3 trailer is in-engine...

And as you can see, I already acknowledged it was pre-rendered  (same as Uncharted 3) to begin with in the original topic as the TC didn't seem to have a problem with it with PS3 exclusives. Of course at that point he started making up "mah roolz".

Have you read -Sixx-'s post? It pwns your comparison quite heavily. And it actually proves that you're claiming nonsense...