You people really are foolish. Look at the bigger perspective here at Uncharted 3. Look at the Success Uncharted 2 had, you sit here and say "a feeling of much of the same" but so? Seriously? I remember Uncharted 2 as being hailed very familiar but polished in such a standard and made so amazing that everyone loved it, because it was damn near perfection.
All naughty dog has to do it manage to improve Uncharted 3 over Uncharted 2 in even the slightest bit, they do that, and Uncharted 3 has the majority of the GOTY awards, no contest.