I just finished Uncharted 2 and i ...

[The Xbox Man]

ishiki said:

neither that nor  mgs4 are the best game of the generation for me. but I'm not the biggest uncharted fan. I am a huge MGS fan, not 4 though(I still liked it).

If they had the exploration, and puzzle solving of tomb raider. To go with the better shooting, and better dialogue of uncharted.

it would probably be the best game ever imo.

Agreed on MGS4, it was a minor disappointment for me. 
Uncharted 2 however is very good.