Not sure I'm the kind of person you're looking for an answer from, as I have to loyalty (in terms of basic brand) to any console really. But, so far this gen the PS3 has been my favourite choice for console gaming as - this gen - it has the titles that interest me the most and which I personally prefer - LittleBigPlanet, Uncharted, Racthet & Clank, and in anticipation the new title from Team ICO. I guess I also still associate some IP more with Playstation, like Silent Hill for example.
However, if Gears, etc. appealed more I'd have bought 360 without any reluctance and happily focused on 360 (actually I've just bought one, but anyway you get the point).
For me the console itself is just a device and I'll purchase whichever consoles appeal to me in terms of their own basic features plus their games library.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
