While I was disappointed with FFXIII, I don't feel like it ever got much hype or praise behind it in the first place to make it qualify as over-rated. By the time I played it my expectations had been lower.
So er, with that in mind, it gets pretty tough for me to pick a game that I feel was over-rated, but I guess I'm going to have to go for Bayonetta. I did really enjoy the game, but it never took me as a '9/10' type of game, I got too used to just dodging to get slow motion and then battering the enemies. I did complete it on the mode where you can't do that, but I just wasn't as 'into' the combat system as some people seem to be.







