Cross-X said:
Kasz216 said:
Cross-X said:
Kasz216 said:
Cross-X said:
Kasz216 said:
Cross-X said:
The point is also that ever since the Chinese revealed that North Korea wasn't involved, South Korea became silent about the situation until the report was released.
Also whether the Chinese are right about a US Mine sinking the Ship isn't the point. Point is the North Korean didn't sink the ship.
|
Again, i've yet to see where they "reveal they weren't involved".
You've literally provided no proof.
The attempts at trying to disprove it have actually greatly contradicted each other.
The "struck a reef" arguement holds no weight.
|
What reason does North Korea have then for firing a Torpedo at a South Korean ship? What makes that so believable?
|
Yeah, it's not like North Korea would ever attack South Korea. I don't know what could ever give me the idea that they would... oh wait, the fact that they have before... and have after.... what with that being what this thread is about. North Korea having just attacked south Korea.
Even NORTH KOREA admits it was a torpedo attack.
http://www.presstv.ir/detail/149355.html
So if not North Korea... who did sink their ship with a torpedo that everyone INCLUDING NORTH KOREA believes was fired?
|
http://www.japanfocus.org/-Tanaka-Sakai/3361
Read the Comments as well.
Involves hypothesizing and yes I cannot provide concrete proof that the North weren't involved however does not mean North Korea actually sunk the ship.
|
So... you want me to read the comments section?
Or the article that's both suggesting it was a war games accident, yet somehow they were hiding from north korea to shink the ship and in fact attack North Korean ships? (Which the US wouldn't do....)
I mean, is it any suprise such a theory was conceived by a novelist?
They don't actually use torpedo's in war games you know. Not even "duds".
The only real suggestion would be that the US intentionally sunk the sub.
The obvious question being... "Why the hell would they do that?"
The obvious answer being... "There is none, because it does the exact opposite of what the US wants."
The US doesn't want a war to happen anymore then China. The only difference is china has more reason to lie.
I mean, just admit it. You were wrong.
|
I can admit I'm wrong and I will. Not need to further discuss such matter. You proved your point and I tried but didn't have the concrete proof to back up other than hyphothesis' including myself.
|
You should note that the hyphothesis' aren't just baseless, but mostly disproven or just outright looney. Like seriously, your last link suggests that the US sunk it to keep South Korea from reconciling with North Korea... and the proof is in the fact that the US is trying to cover it up just like how they covered up 9/11 was an insidejob.
Despite the fact that the US has been trying to activly reconcile North and South Korea for decades. Heck, North Korea's biggest problems with the peace talks were they were 6 party... and not just the two Koreas the US last time I checked. Cause they know the US would give more for stable peace.
There literally are no credible hypothesis left outside of a North Korean job. Even without proof. There is literally no other country including south korea itself who would of had anything to gain from it.
