The not-quite official GOTY thread (2010)

[Antabus]

Conegamer said:

Antabus said:

1) Maybe the people who made the list does not consider it to be goty-material..?

2) SMG2 is at best action-adventure list, PGA11 on best individual sports game, FIFA/Madden on best team sports game, rock band 3 on best music game, Kirby's epic yarn on best graphics(?!).

3) Maybe it is a good game?

4) Where it belongs. ;P

 

2.) Which wii game you would want to be nominated in following categories? This should be interesting, since those are some of my favourite genres. :P

-Shooter

-RPG

-Driving

Shooter- Goldeneye

RPG- Arc Rise Fantasia/ Monster Hunter Tri

Driving-F1 2010

In fairness, don't forget with RPG Xenoblade and The Last Story coming out, Shooter has the CODs, Primes and Conduit, and driving has Mario Kart. Not a "bad" list with poor genres for the Wii!

So you think Goldeneye is a better shooter than Reach,Bioshock2,Black ops and Bad company 2? I guess you can see it being better than some of those games... I don't. Critics too disagree with you.

http://www.metacritic.com/game/wii/goldeneye-007

Monster Hunter Tri had a higher metascore than FF XIII but that is not a rpg, is it? Arc rise fantasia looks definitely goty material:

http://www.metacritic.com/game/wii/arc-rise-fantasia

F1 2010 is not a wii game...?

 

And yes, monster hunter is where it belongs. Not on the goty lists.