VGC Mafia Round 22 Sign-up Thread

[dtewi]

nordlead said:

dtewi said:

nordlead said:

Well, let's look at it this way.

Doctor claims townie. Town turns to lynch a scum. Scum claims doctor!!!

what do you do now?

Marvel at the fact that the "doctor" doesn't die the next day. Then promptly lynch him. 

except by then the real doctor has been picked off because he probably didn't believe the scum doctor claim and said so. Also, we've had plenty of games that can easily expalin why the person you would think die doesn't. I'd only subscribe to that tactic if we knew we were playing a vanilla game with only 1 doctor and 1 cop.

This is all based on the assumption that a scum would role-claim doctor. In a vanilla game, they would never ever do that. In a power game, it becomes much more dicey, but I think a doctor for a scum is a good trade-off.