Playstation Move Vs. Xbox 360 Kinect: Metacritic

[zgamer5]

kowenicki said:

Fumanchu said:

I guess the main problem with adding in games that have recently become 'move enabled' such as Heavy Rain and Resident Evil 5 etc. is that their reviews were based on a different control scheme.  If Metacritic had two scores then there shouldn't be a problem.

I agree.. and same goes for future titles too.   Also use the check...  "If MOVE didnt exist would game X still exist?"

TBH if this comparison is to be any use then it needs to concentrate on MOVE/KINECT only titles.  Not ones which offer it as an alternative control scheme.

why? were comparing move and kinect as a whole, ofcourse games are reviewed according to their dual shock 3 versions, but the only difference is the controls, so if we can get any articles on the controls of move on those games we can have an idea on what it would get if it was only move enabled.

also if you want to compare only move vs only kinect games, games such as the fight and time crisis should be left out, because in their case they are being compared to full pledged games. other then that i expect kinect games to have a higher meta.