Playstation Move Vs. Xbox 360 Kinect: Metacritic

[Fumanchu]

cory.ok said:

Seece said:

It has nothing to do with my bias, if Fable 3 still had Kinect support I wouldn't have added that either. Don't come up with your conspiracy theorys to settle your point. You expect this list to be an overall list of games that support Move and Kinect, it isn't, I already explained that and why I've made it this way.

conspiracy theories? lol i dont think i know what youre talking about, but anyways, to further make my point:

38 of the announced 54 titles that will support move will also support DS3 support, while only 4 of the 42 kinect games games announced will support another input method.

move is gonna end up with a pretty small list compared to kinect if youre going in"terms of sole motion controls", though move will support more games, the comparison makes no sense

I think you could very easily turn that around though and say why it's the only fair comparison that you can make.  Here's why; if you look at the DS3 and Xbox controller supported games you run into the trouble of guessing how much of the review score is based upon the motion controls aspect or the traditional controller mechanics, which is fundamental to the gameplay.  For instance, using Resident Evil 5 as an example - none of the separated reviews that count towards the amalgamated metacritic total ever considered the move controls, some would say a comparison using that game makes no sense.