djstrykermx on 10 October 2010
Haven't played MOH yet (obviously) but RDR is a gem, it's really really good. I dislike GTAs story but liked the open world, driving, mission structure, etc. RDR's story is much much better than any GTA (imo).
I'd suggest to wait for a few reviews to MOH to pop up, read them and then make your purchase based on what you read or see.
If you had to ask me, Red Dead all the way.
