I suspect this has already been said, but oh well.
This is not so much a criticism of Kinect, as it is a criticism of the games he played.
Kinectimals seems to have a bug or two, but we have no idea if that is a result of Kinect's flaws or the programs. Other than that he seemed impressed with the game, saying that it would be good for young children (ie its target audience)
Kinect Sports again is criticised for the controls, but it is for not doing things that we know Kinect has the capability to do. It definitely sounds like this is a software fault with the game itself. And keep in mind Wii Sports had some control issues too (the bowling had some issues at times and putting was a nightmare)
Kinect Adventures is described as "pretty entertaining the first time, but mostly because of the sociability and jumping and not to the game itself has no direct challenge or, again, giving or precise game control" - google translator.
That's pretty much exactly how I would describe Mario Party, and that series does well for itself
Kinect Joyride - the only criticism levelled here is that Mario Kart: Wii is better. Of course it damn well is, MK:Wii is the best arcade racer of the generation, and he expects this team to beat that, with their first ever motion controlled game?
Dance Central is described as a pretty decent game, doing exactly what is on the label.
I don't see why people are quite so pissed
