First Legit Halo : Reach Review - 9.5 / 10 !!!

[rakugakist]

reidlosdog said:

yo_john117 said:

A decent score but what is sad is they gave Halo 3 a 9.8/10  So they basically think Halo 3 is better then Halo Reach.

And the fact that they rated MW2 over Halo Reach is just a pure insult.

I know this is going to sound biased, but GI gives 10's to PS3 Games.  seriously.  Look at the list provided.  they really do have a thing for PS3, and they literally dislike Halo.  No one in the office plays the game hardcore, and no one was actually excited for the games release.  Just saying, that score is an actual shock to me.  I'm almost certain Halo Reach deserves a 10/10.  Looking at how well the AI plays, and how well the multiplayer (Forge, FireFight, then actual multiplayer!?!?), GI better have an actually LISTED reason for taking of .5

@yo_john

How do you know it's an insult?  Have you played Halo Reach?  Do you know it's better than MW2?  Also, scores typically are one man's subjective opinions. Don't let it get to you so much.

@ reidlosdog

How do you know that no one in the office plays the game hardcore or that anyone was actually excited for the games release. Especially figuring that it made the cover last month.  And how are you so certain that Reach deserves a 10/10?

I mean seriously, a 9.5 is a really good score.  Why is everybody freaking out so much?  And why don't we wait until everybody has had a chance to play it before we complain about the score.