Alan Wake big disappointment

[Doobie_wop]

themanwithnoname said:

Doobie_wop said:

Playing on Nightmare isn't going to make you like the game more, on my brief replay I only noticed more flaws than I did on my first play through.

@Selnor: Please don't overrate the game so much, I can understand if you loved it and that's fine, but when someone overlooks all it's flaws and then tries and defend the game it only makes the game worse in my eyes because it cannot defend itself based on its own merits. That other guy was wrong for calling you out, just don't get baited so easily.

So I suppose you know better than selnor how he should feel? Just because you were bothered by the game's flaws doesn't mean everyone else should be.

I didn't say anything about Selnor outside of the obvious, which is that he loved the game, something he has admitted to many times. My feelings of the game shouldn't hurt his feelings of the game, I was just saying that the game should be able to rely on it's own merits if its as good as he says and that he should ignore the overly negative guy who's posting against him for attention. 

The flaws in the game aren't based on my opinion, it's based on practical game design, it's still a fantastic game, but it does have it's flaws and that's ok. It's up to everyone else to choose to ignore or accept them, I obviously see them for what they are, annoyances that hurt my experience.