Reasonable on 11 August 2010
I thought it was a solid 8.5.
Good engine, if actually somewhat wasted on the final game due to the shift away from open world during development.
The gameplay was fine just a little too repetitive at time and the mood was a little too Western thriller (despite Remedy clearly trying to channel Twin Peaks) and not genuinely wierd enough (a'la Silent Hill or Twin Peaks) for my liking.
But it had a decent story and was solid in every area with some particularly nice lighting effects.
I wouldn't mind a sequel, but I'd prefer if they went for the Silent Hill 2 level of horror vibe.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
