Arizona "your papers please" immigration law

[Moren]

HappySqurriel said:

morenoingrato said:

TheRealMafoo said:

morenoingrato said:

To be honest, this law is totally nonsense.

Any resident, tourist, or anone just won't fell safe since they'll have to take their papers everywhere, the an forget them, they're likely to lose them, and inmigrants are people too. And they dont affect america in any way. The only reason this law was made is because the arizona goverment are racists

wow

I am the least racist person I know, and I am 100% for the law.

To call Arizona racist for passing the law, is to call the US racist for having the same law. A federal officer is allowed to stop anyone they feel is here illegally, and investigate there citizenship. That person doesn't even need to commit a crime first.

Arizona just wants to help the Feds enforce there own law. How does that make one racist and the other not?

Also, the "they dont affect america in any way" is just 100% wrong. You don't include 12 million people into a society, and get no affect.

 

the inmigrants do the jobs no american wants to do, the degradating jobs.

And even you say it. When an officer "feels like they're there illegally"

for non ilegals, a waste of time, a risk

for ilegals they have 49 states to go, and they are also humans

The myth that illegal immigrants are doing jobs that citizens and legal immigrants are unwilling to do is unfounded. Since these individuals are often paid less than the market rate legitimate businesses pay their employees, and are often paid below minimum wage, the truth is that illegal immigrants are doing jobs that citizens and legal immigrants are unwilling or unable to do for what they’re paid. When illegal immigrants are pushed out wages are forced upwards and there is no difficulty finding workers for most of these jobs.

Now, with that said, within 10 seconds of talking with someone you will have a fairly decent idea of whether they’re an immigrant or not; from there, there are obvious signs whether someone is in the country legally or not, that most individuals would pick up within a couple of months of doing a job like police work. If I was to put a rough guestimate on it, I would expect that somewhere between 90% and 95% of people the police suspected of being illegal immigrants would be illegal immigrants, and most of the remaining would be very recent immigrants.

People I know, they do jobs that no one else does. If you go to a small ny superarket: latins, india, asia

taxis, latin, asia, india.

All the jobs that seems "shamefull" goes to the illegal.

And yes, 10 seconds, you know they're not native. So police will bother them, make them lose valuable time, if they're not ilegal.

If they are ilegal, thats a pretty cruel law, you know. Many ilegals travel to pay family debts and give their family money. I know a couple of examples of families who  has their husband in usa and sends them money to survive