By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

If they like baseball even a little bit, I'd get them MLB Power Pros. Very easy to pick up and play, but so deep that hours and hours are gone, by the time you turn off the Wii.

Super Mario Galaxy is also a good choice, as you can't go wrong with a "perfect game". Getting 60 stars in that game is supposed to be a lot of frustration free fun, I have heard that getting 121 stars is an exercise in hair pulling (I am currently at 40, but my 9 year old son has already beat it by getting 60).