Heavy Rain: Incredible graphics, unique interface, compelling story. One of the most captivating games I've played this gen.
Alan Wake: Some of the best graphics I've ever seen (at night--sorta average during the daytime scenes), thought provoking story, incredibly tense atmosphere.
Bayonetta: Possibly the best action game of all time. Gameplay perfected. Best new character of the year.
Super Mario Galaxy 2: Refined and polished like no other. Pure gaming bliss.
Mass Effect 2: Storyline that sucks you in, great graphics, all around great game.
God of War 3: Haven't played it but the reviews can't be wrong. It gives its audience what it wants.
All of these games (except GoW3 since I haven't played it, yet) get my highest recommendation. It's hard to imagine a game in the next few months topping them.
