Alan Wake or Red Dead Redemption?

[Lolcislaw]

Cueil said:

Lolcislaw said:

Thanks for the input, i've decided to get Alan Wake; got if for quite cheap plus im in a mood for a dark game. 

so how do you like it?  Only a couple of weeks and the new episode comes out

Well im going to start playing tomorrow when i get a chance to plug my 360 to my parents HD TV , looking forward to it.