I dunno about you, but I think Kevin Butler is right.

[richardhutnik]

bugrimmar said:

I don't think I can really play games without anything to hold or pressing a button. I would feel like an idiot pretending to turn the wheel of a nonexistent thing in my hand. I feel like it would be, as Kevin Butler said, like third grade *pew pew pew*.

This isn't meant to bash Kinect in any way. I think it will be a great success. But I personally can't bring myself to wave my hands and feet around in pretend space. I would feel kinda stupid doing it.

Does holding wants with lighted bulbs at the end really excite people either?  Do you feel cool doing this?  What I am seeing is the guys who cover E3, end up thinking they look silly holding the lighted wands.

Ok, how about a game like boxing, for example, where you just box?