Overall i thought they were both poor.
Neither showed really anything new that is for the hardcore gamer. MS showed more gameplay footage of their games while Sony showed more shiney trailers.
If i break it down and think about it personally i felt the gameplay showing of Reach/Gears/Black ops was better then the gameplay showing of Sorcerer/Twisted Metal/MOH.
Sony talked more and showed more iritating things like the ads, the Kevin Butler bit which made zero sense. I still don't get that! He comes on and slags off MS, say's it's time to show the games, gives a speech, then forgets to show the games...Which meant the point was what again? The othewr thing that annoyed me was they showed montages of games they had just shown about 5 times!
MS were the same, they just showed a lot of pointless things, like the whole ESPN thing....
So i put it as a tie, they were both poor.
