I think it's cute that people think that a developer decided to introdue a politically motivated and interstesing story doesn't deserve GoTY because it didn't involve an Italian plumber jumping planets.
Admit it; both games are brilliant and if you don't see the innovation in either BioShock or SMG, you aren't paying much attention to either. There are four or five games that I don't mind seeing get GoTY so stop getting your panties in such a bundle over it.

Or check out my new webcomic: http://selfcentent.com/







