So I think at this point it's safe to say
Nintendo>>>>>>>>>>>Sony>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Microsoft
I like to judge the showing based off the surprises. After all, that's why most gamers get excited for and watch E3 isn't it?
Nintendo had a healthy showing of surprises (if you exclude the leaks and rumors). They had the Goldeneye Remake, Mario Sports Mix, and the megaton IMO, a new Donkey Kong Country. And of course, the 3DS blowout, with announcements of its features, game lineup, and appearence. No Vitality Sensor was odd though. A -
Sony had a decent amount of surprises if you're interested in the Move. But for the core gamer not interested in motion controls, there really were few surprises. The main ones were the announcement of Portal 2, GT5 release date, and the big one, Twisted Metal. The Move stuff was mostly just same old core games with tacked on motion or stuff Wii has alreay done. Sorcery did look neat though. C
Microsoft showed they have no ounce of creativity in their bones when they decided to ripp off virtually EVERY type of successful Wii game, and in a half assed manner on top of that. Natal just looked akward and tiring to use, and most of the games looked bland and of bad quality. We saw some decent new footage of things like Gears 3, but litterally NO new core games announced. Terrible showing. D -
