Does Lady Gaga keeps getting uglier and uglier as time pass?

[Stefan.De.Machtige]

thelalaby said:

Stefan.De.Machtige said:

thelalaby said:

.:Dark Prince:. said:

Well she was never good-looking, but yeah the big bad change is the eyebrows. Seriously, they mess the whole face up!

But i'm still obsessed with her, she has talent and catchy songs that i can't get out of my mind... ever.

STOLEN catchy songs :P

And the Alejandro video is disturbing! And this is coming from a gay guy. I liked Telephone's video better.

And even if they're not stolen ( or a tribute??), then a single song doensn't have that much to do with Gaga's talent. A producer and a songwriter do most of the work there. A catchy song has far more to do with those people. 

She does the style really well, the dancing good and the singing decent (sometimes good). I quess that's Pop right? Mostly Style over substance.

 

A tribute this isn't! It would have been considered a reference or an homage if Lady GaGa hadn't claimed that she CREATIVELY written the song. And this isn't a single song, I have previously stated that "Dance In The Dark" is also very familiar to two of Madonna's songs (as another example). Oh and I think vocally she's really good, every performance of her song "Speechless" is just plain great but her dancing in general is alright mainly because she's always plauged by some crazy outfit which makes her hips seem kinda slow, but you know it gets the job done.

And pop isn't exactly pop style over substance, at least not entirely. You have people like Whitney Houston and Celine Dion who have never exactly been known for style but are among the best-selling artists ever. Madonna (who is my favorite singer ever btw) is a perfect mix between the two, she's had her share of mindless dancing music but then again she had her album "Ray of Light" which remains until this day among the most spiritual, emotionally-satisfying album I've ever heard. And Madonna has LOTS of style. So you know, if Lady GaGa keeps the focus on her style instead of her music and keeps repeating the same chorus structure (like she did in the first two albums) or "pays tribute" too much to other songs, she will end up losing more fans and joining the ranks of Cyndi Lauper who was once insanely popular and a pop icon but now is barely recognized.

I put '??' behind tribute, to mean it was  guestionable. I agree with you.

In hindsight i should have added Pop in these days. Whitney and Celine are real singing diva's. Although Whitney seems to be falling - her new tour is not a real comeback. Celine is still big - and even pregnant.

Imo, Madonna was more Style over substance. She made her name by shocking people - everthing from religion too Politics. Gaga takes to her, but then in a pure stylish way, with design.