If GTA4 isn't a 10/10 game, why did it get reviews like it did?

[oniyide]

people complaining about it being to dark and not fun, I think you forgot what GTA was about, the guy is a criminal, its not supposed to be light. with that being said, some should give ballad of gay tony a try, it is lighter in tone and you get the best weapons of the bat, you can even manage and dance at clubs