So you are already calling it GOTY with games like ME2 and GOW3 already out and also upcoming games like Fallout New Vegas, Metroid other M and Halo Reach? And still you wont give it a 10? Its great game indeed definitely GOTY material, even though i wouldn't call it that yet. But if you don't think this game deserves a 10 then you shouldn't already call it GOTY. It deserves a 10 in my book btw.