By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Rpruett said:
Just a thought....because it's more of the same? Mario 64 / Mario Galaxy / Mario Galaxy 2 re-skinned versions of the same fundamental principle. And (personal opinion) are heavily overrated and the last true great (10/10 deserving Mario) was Mario 64.

The same people jumping in front of moving cars to defend the 10/10 scores are the same people who bash God of War 3 or games of that caliber for doing more of the same, or being stale. Well Pot meet Kettle.


In my personal opinion the game is above average and certainly not 'perfect'. While it's well made, it seems like it's predictable Nintendo hype. Just like Super Smash Brothers was.

People want full sequels to these great games not these re-skinned, practical clone efforts that Nintendo has been notorious for.

I agree. Also, I played the first one and I didn't like it, but I though it was a great game, just not for me. I guess I only like Mario in 2D. I personally think that no game should get a 10/10, because there is no game can be perfect. A 9.5 seems more reasonable to me.