By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Smidlee on 24 May 2010
Edit Thread
slowmo said:
Smidlee said:
slowmo said:
CGI-Quality said:
I think some of you guys ARE being a tad out of line. This is an instance where, yes there's some stuff that I don't agree with in there, selnor hasn't intended any backlash. Some of you are just using the opportunity to bash and thrash him, and it's not justified right now.

I agree 100%, if you don't like the guys opinion just don't enter his threads.

If you don't want people to give their opinion of a review then stop creating threads about game reviews. Why write a review if you are afraid of what people will say about your review?  A review for someone who I already knew would give the game a 10/10 doesn't have much value to me. I see nothing wrong pointing this out. This is reason why I don't put much faith in gamers review like at Amazon as you get  too many 5/5 amd 1/5 scores.

See the posts above, very few of you criticizing him are doing so for the content of the review, just the score and who he is.

A review is for those who haven't bought the game yet or am I missing something. If a reviewer has a strong bias then that effects how helpful and creditable a review is. It's nothing personal it just a pattern found in Selnor's reviews. Some have help the review to be more  creditable (more down to earth) like Reasonable post.