Odd that you log of rather fast after making this thread? Anyways, I am currently playing Super Mario Galaxy 2. (Yay for midnight releases) Take the 1st Mario Galaxy and throw in a few hundred pounds more of imagination and that is what you will get. I have been playing it for over 3hrs already and I am not far in at all. But then again I am getting every star out of every galaxy and taking my time. I would give you details about why it is such a blast, but I shall not post spoilers and ruin anyone's experience.
RDR is the kind of game I would play no more than an hour. It just is not my type. You can easily see what I would pick to keep for good. However, it all depends on which you think you will get more playtime out of. They are both probably great games for their style of game. Why in the world you would want to sell a great game back so fast is beyond me. I think you would be better off buying one now and then buying the other down the road.
