|
Halo:CE deserved every bit of it. It was the best console FPS at the time, and despite no online had the best multiplayer to boot. Had a lot of fun in the system link days.
I'd say Halo 2 deserved a slightly lower score because of the weak Campaign, but then again the Live portion of it was amazing and well makes up for that. I missed the old Halo 1 pistol but that was about it in regards to MP.
Halo 3 had a great theater feature, forge, even better online abilities, and four player co-op. The campaign was decent but not great. This deserves a slightly lower score to some but was amazing in m book.
Halo Wars is a great RTS and hugely underrated *CONSOLE* RTS. When you compare it to the likes of Starcraft It's crap, but on the console I would say it was the second best console RTS ever release - behind Starcraft 64.
Halo ODST deserves It's rating and not much more. It had a great campaign and firefight was fun, but was more or less a glorified expansion.
So bottom line is I would agree with all the ratings except Halo Wars, it should be 88% or more borderline 89%.
It's just that simple.