I'm calling it now... Red Dead Redemption will be Game of the Year

[perpride]

For me the GOTY will almost certainly be FFXIII.

But RDR is looking for a contender...but when you consider:

ME2
SMG2
Zelda
Alane Wake
God of War 3
Possibility of GT5
Possibility of LBP2

in that order....it looks pretty tough.