Cross-X on 19 May 2010
Visually Mass Effect 2 is more appealing.
People did say that the character models looked dated, etc for Alan Wake whereas Mass Effect 2 wasn't criticized for anything in the graphics department. I'm sure many would've seen the X360 version vs PC version of Mass Effect 2. BioWare did a bloody good job of making the graphics of the X360 version match closely to the PC version.
Course Gears 2 looks fab but ME2 is still better overall.
