Anyone else a bit offended at claims Heavy Rain's writing is Oscar Worthy?

[LordTheNightKnight]

CGI-Quality said:

LordTheNightKnight said:
"Mummelman is right though, discussion is healthy, but only within reason. You made this thread feeling offended by some words from a few folks who enjoyed a game's story, a story that you've yet to actually experience for yourself. Why do you think people have jumped on your case?"

No, I stated later that the offense was from the lack of discussion before, and people haven't jumped on me.

And just because you don't like to judge the story without playing it doesn't mean the quality will not be evident if you are not playing it. Most of the cut scenes from Resident Evil don't magically change in quality whether you are playing the game or watching videos on youtube. They are still so bad it's good no matter what.

You keep telling yourself that you're justified and I'll remember your reactions to people who speak poorly about Wii games they've yet to play.

Again, I'm not discussing the game. I'm duscussing the story. Pretending that's a counter to my point shows you still don't get my point.

If people can see the story of a Wii game and find it bad or good, their opinions are still legitimate since they aren't judging the rest of the game.