SlumsofOhio on 17 May 2010
The original Red Dead game (Revolver) was made by Capcom, not Rockstar. So both games were bound to be different. Hence, why I said "original". Rockstar expanded on Revolver, They didn't start over from scrach.
Red Dead Redemption would be the first Red Dead game built from beginning to end by Rockstar. Hopefully this cleared up some confusion.
