What kind of phenomenon is Heavy Rain?

[epicurean]

CGI-Quality said:

richardhutnik said:

epicurean said:
This thread was about as necessary as this reply...

Perhaps I'll go calling other games phenomenon's in threads about those games and see if we can get some more threads created as to whether or not they are.

In the other thread, where the user posted the GTA-Heavy Rain video, that person called Heavy Rain a phenomenon.  I tried to discuss that in there, and CGI said that I was derailing the thread.  So, what else to do, but discuss that comment in another thread?  And that is what I did. 

No. I quoted you strictly based on your unnecessary comments, it had nothing to do with you disagreeing with those words and you know it.

You went in there and talked about "fanboys", or how "the game wouldn't be praised if it were multiplat", etc.... All things that had nothing to do with anything.

I didn't go into the other thread, as it said "spoiler", but this just seems like a thread made to talk negatively about the game.  Perhaps I'm missinterpreting it.  But if the next thread that comes up is "Is Heavy Rain the best entertainment ever created" with the OP saying no, then I'm thinking that would be trolling, right?