Entroper on 15 December 2007
I agree about the analog sticks. These games were designed to be played with a mouse and keyboard. I saw a video of TF2 being played on a 360 controller, and it looked, in a word, unplayable. You can't snap around to look for someone behind you, you can't aim quickly (which completely screws up the Sniper and Scout), you can't take out sentry guns nearly as effectively -- the whole game is just broken.
I wouldn't think Portal would be as bad. There aren't many situations in Portal that require both fast and precise aiming. Then again, I wasn't really thinking about aiming while thoroughly enjoying the game -- I may be taking the mouse and keyboard for granted. Still, it can't be half as difficult as playing TF2 on a gamepad.
