Selnors Graphics prediction Alan Wake review thread.

[binary solo]

coolbeans said:

binary solo said:

coolbeans said:

binary solo said:
Since we're learning lessons:

If you are console graphics HD whore then you need to be on PS3, it's that simple.

You may want to change the wording a bit.  360 has around 20 more games that run in native 720p than PS3 does (at this moment).  Just pointing that out

Point? More =/= better. I never said you should ditch 360, but if you want the best of the best from a console graphics technical perspective then you need PS3.

I'm not trying to say that.  Only to point out you should change the wording of a "console gfx HD whore".  Putting it in the same context as an HD TV channel whore, which do you think that person will go for: a cable network with 50 1080p channels or one with 40 1080p channels?  I'm not having a problem with you making that sort of remark in PS3's favor, just how you put it in context. 

I would argue the part I quoted completely as well but.........I'll just respectfully not bother.  We have our difference of opinion :)

Well the TV analogy is a tad flawed, because as I said, I'm not saying you need to rid yourself of the 360, or discard any notion of buying one. You can only subscribe to one cable service. You can own both HD consoles. In any case I don't see how what I said would be interpretted to mean PS3 has a greater quantity of 720p+ games. The debates and discussions around graphics have always been about quality not quanitity. Your first reply was the first time I've ever seen a relative quantification of native HD games between PS3 and 360.

Having said that I accept that a better phrasing would have been "HD console graphics whore" to make it more clear that it's the graphics part not the HD part that's the main subject.

Readers please consider my firt post to be amended according to the above sentence.

It's not my opinion that PS3 has better graphics capability than 360 that I'm reflecting upon. My opinion on that subject is completely worthless because I have no technical expertise upon which to make an educated judgement; and almost no presonal experience of the 360 to make an informed judgement. It's my observation that the general industry consensus is beginning to settle on that point of view. If my observation is wildly off base I'm more than happy to be corrected. I am looking for objectivity here, which is hard to get in this industry.