Alan Wake Versus Super Mario Galaxy 2. Predictions: Reviews and Sales

[johnappseed84]

Khuutra said:

johnappseed84 said:
As far as Meta's go, even though Alan Wake only has an 84, that's right up there with the last two Mario games. A couple of points higher than Kart (82) and only a few points lower than New Super Mario Brother's Wii (87).

This is kind of a weird parallel to draw

The only proper comparison is another 3-D Mario

So what's the first Galaxy's metascore?

Why is the 3d Mario the only proper comparisson when other posters already asserted that any Mario game was vastly superior to Alan Wake?