Official Alan Wake Review Thread (Metacritic)

[maximus22]

Aldro said:

rccsetzer said:
So, GOTY is in Mass Effect 2 hand until now. But i think the real dispute will be between SMG2 and GT5.

What no GoW3 ;_;?

 

Naw I know what you mean, truthfully ME2 probably has a bigger chance of GOTY over GoW3.

SMG2 and GT5, Agree but ill also add Halo Reach (Hellooo its Halooo lol).

Hmm, I don't know about this.  I love both of these games about equally but for very different reasons.  There are many areas where GOW3 destroys ME2 and any other game for that matter.  It is just that astounding.  I guess if I had to give an edge it would be to ME2 but it is almost too close to call.