The only review site I pay attention to is Gametrailers, as they actually take into account the full game and show you examples of what they're talking about when they're pointing out specific parts of the review. However, even with Gametrailers, they have specific bias towards certain systems. Spefically they seem to have a positive bias towards the PS3 (upscoring those games) and somewhat of a heavy bias against Nintendo (being rather harsh on those games and often downscoring games on the Wii and DS for things they wouldn't elsewhere). So even with Gametrailers, I have to take their reviews with a heavy grain of salt.
I find all other sites downscore games for petty reasons or are very inconsistent. And they have changed many times in the last few years, with multiple different editors coming and going. And with the recent firings or mass exoduses from such sites as GameSpot and IGN, its even more apparent that those sites are going to change even more. Its pointless to try to read those sites, let alone their reviews, when they can't even keep ahold of their own staff.
Six upcoming games you should look into:
