The gameplay is also the part where I'm not fully convinced.
Visually, they have me. A good atmosphere in a game is very good and can keep you hooked for a single playthrough. But it usually fades over subsequent playthroughs. So will the game have enough to offer to warrant a purchase over a rent?
So far, the many videos don't really show much diversity when it comes to gameplay, which is the reason why I'm a bit concerned.