You can only pick 3 of the following.

[Chairman-Mao]

SmokedHostage said:

High Quality gameplay - The most important. What is a game with low quality gameplay?

High replay value (Flexibility/Content/etc.) - 2nd most important. I only buy a game if it has high replay value.

High quality music Couldn't care less about the music

High quality graphics - My third most important. Great graphics don't make a game, but horrible graphics can break a game. lol

High quality storytelling Not a big deal for me since I usually play shooters/sports/racing

High quality plot Isn't plot basically the same as storytelling?

High quality originality/innovation Important, but gets beat out narrowly by graphics

Choose.